Can MRI results predict surgery success?  Workers’ compensation employees with an injured neck or low back may have a cervical or lumbar MRI documenting a bulging or herniated disc.  The herniated disc causes a pinched nerve resulting in radicular pain down the arm or leg.  Surgery may be recommended.  Unfortunately there is no correlation between pre-surgical MRI results and post-surgery recovery.

Magnetic resonance imaging–more commonly known as MRI–provides doctors with computerized pictures of tissues inside the body. This machine creates images that look like slices of the body. If a person has neck pain, for example, doctors can use MRI to determine exactly where the problem is and where to operate. But can the MRI give an accurate picture of whether the surgery will be a success?

In one study seventy-three patients requiring surgery for spinal stenosis were reviewed. Fifty of the patients were men; 23 were women. Their ages ranged from 43 to 81 years old. The average age was 64. 

The authors studied MRI scans taken of each patient before surgery. The authors wanted to compare whether certain qualities of the MRI were common in patients who didn’t do well after surgery. If patients with a particular finding on the MRI didn’t get good results from surgery, doctors might know not to suggest surgery for these kinds of patients.

The results showed that, for the most part, MRIs don’t predict how well a patient will do after surgery. The findings of one type of MRI pattern suggested there was greater damage to the spinal cord tissues. Patients with this MRI pattern tended to do poorly after surgery. But since only four of these patients were in the study, the results weren’t conclusive.

A combination of the patients’ ages, certain MRI patterns, and duration of symptoms seemed to be good predictors of how well the participants would do after surgery. Younger patients whose MRI scans didn’t suggest a lot of damage and whose symptoms hadn’t lasted as long were more likely to get good results from surgery.

MRIs can give lots of information about the spine. However, doctors don’t yet know how to use this information to predict how well people will do after surgery.  The worker’s compensation clients represented by McCormick Law Office attorneys get the best results they can from surgery, then we work to get them the worker’s compensation benefits they need to move on.